The question keeps following Brian Niccol around, and on Friday he answered it again. Speaking at Yahoo Finance Invest, the Starbucks chief executive was asked about Chipotle, the chain he used to run, and whether Starbucks might one day own more than one brand. His answer was steady. Not now. Maybe someday. And only if the opportunity clears a very high bar.
The Chipotle question has been hanging around since early October, when the Financial Times reported that Starbucks had worked with advisers on a possible proposal for the burrito chain. Starbucks shut that down days later, with a spokesperson saying plainly that the company is not buying Chipotle. A day after Starbucks reported fiscal fourth quarter results on October 29, Niccol told Bloomberg Television that a multi-brand Starbucks was “one of those possibilities,” adding that the company’s scale creates an opening to go beyond being a one-brand company. Asked whether it could happen someday, he said he would “never say never.”
Friday’s remarks sounded much the same, with one useful addition. Niccol described what a deal would have to look like to earn his attention. Any brand joining Starbucks would need to be iconic and category-defining, fit the company’s culture, and gain something real from Starbucks’ strengths in media buying, real estate, supply chains and developing talent. Yahoo Finance also noted that no official offer for Chipotle has been made. The message for regulars is simple enough. The growth plan comes first, and the deal talk stays on a distant shelf.
What the experts think
Restaurant industry watchers are not surprised Niccol is keeping the door ajar, and most of them are not urging him to walk through it. Jonathan Maze, editor-in-chief of Restaurant Business, put it bluntly to Inc.: “Most of the time, when a single chain buys another one, it doesn’t work. And investors know this.” Roger Beaudoin of Restaurant Rockstars sees the other side. Starbucks has real estate know-how, purchasing power, digital ordering and a loyalty program that another brand could plug into, and a second concept could reach customers at other times of day. Even so, he warns that size alone does not guarantee fatter profits, and that brands often do best by sticking with the one thing that made them famous. Paul Nary, a management professor at Wharton, called the case for diversifying “rather thin” so far, and said the most sensible move, if one ever comes, would be into a related business.
The coffeehouse still comes first
Niccol’s own caveat matters here. He has said repeatedly that Starbucks can hit its growth targets without buying anything, and the latest numbers back up the focus on the core business. Adjusted earnings came in at 80 cents a share in the fiscal fourth quarter, ahead of expectations, with global comparable sales up 7.2 percent and U.S. comparable sales up 7.7 percent. It was the fifth straight quarter of comparable-sales growth. The near-term work he pointed to on Friday was not about acquisitions at all. It was an AI rethink of the drive-thru, portable foods and collagen drinks, all aimed at better service and stronger afternoons.
For regulars, the takeaway is simple. Your Starbucks is not about to become a food court, and Niccol knows the turnaround still needs his full attention. The multi-brand idea is a someday conversation, the kind a confident CEO can afford to have out loud while the coffee keeps improving. If the day ever comes when another brand joins the family, the test will be the one Niccol set himself. It has to be a brand worth the name on the door.
Sources:
- AD HOC News: Starbucks stock: Niccol keeps core growth plan in focus
- Seeking Alpha: Starbucks CEO: “I would never say never to a multi-brand future”
- Inc.: Starbucks Could Become More Than a Coffee Company. Its Greatest Strength May Be the Problem
- TipRanks: Starbucks (SBUX) CEO Won’t Rule Out Future Acquisitions