It started as a social media dare and ended as a real drink order. People are bringing hollowed-out pumpkins to Starbucks and asking partners to pour their Pumpkin Spice Lattes straight into them. A USA TODAY reporter tried it this week, and to everyone’s surprise, including hers, it worked.
How the pumpkin cup works
The trick is in the prep. Carve out a small pumpkin the night before and let it dry overnight. At the store, tell the team you already have a cup, then make the ask face to face. The reporter got a yes: her PSL went into the pumpkin, finished with whipped cream and a dusting of pumpkin pie spice. She reports the drink tasted just like it would in a regular cup, with no pumpkin bits coming up the straw. Her one regret was size. Next time, she says, she would bring a bigger pumpkin.
Not every store will say yes, and that is worth knowing before you try. Some partners turn the request down because of food safety rules, since a pumpkin is not a standard cup. The easy workaround is to order your drink as usual and pour it into your pumpkin yourself, asking for whipped cream on the side for the full effect.
A trend, not a menu item
This is a customer idea, not a Starbucks program, and Starbucks has not officially weighed in on it. That distinction matters for the partners on the other side of the counter. If you give it a try, keep it friendly and low pressure: ask, accept a no gracefully, and tip well for the extra effort. The fun of the trend is in the novelty, and the best version of it is one where everyone behind the counter is smiling too.
Halloween is less than a week away, so the window for this one is short. If a PSL in a pumpkin sounds like your kind of fall ritual, carve the pumpkin tonight and give it a shot tomorrow. Just bring the bigger pumpkin.
Sources: